What does evidence tier actually mean on compound pages?

RORena Okoro· 14 days ago

Research & educational use only. This content is not medical advice. Consult a qualified healthcare professional before using any peptide compound.

I keep seeing compounds labeled Tier 1 through Tier 4 on their pages. Can someone explain in plain language what those tiers actually mean and why a compound with lots of animal studies can still be a low tier?

I think I understand that human randomized trials are the top, but I do not fully get why observational studies rank below them.

8

2 Replies

10
DCDr. Sarah Chen researcher· Expert· 13 days ago

The tiers rank how confidently we can attribute an effect to the compound. Tier 1 is human randomized controlled trials, where randomization balances known and unknown confounders so a difference in outcome can be credited to the intervention. Tier 2 is human observational data, which is suggestive but vulnerable to confounding. Tier 3 is animal-only, and Tier 4 is theoretical or mechanistic.

That is why a compound with dozens of animal studies and no human trials stays at Tier 3: volume of animal work does not substitute for a controlled human result.

Accepted solution
8
BLBea Lindqvist· Senior· 13 days ago

The confounding intuition is the part that made it stick for me. Observational groups differ in ways you cannot fully measure.

Sign in to join the discussion.